“ I got seated immediately and the waitress came to the table almost immediately she's quite good at what she does I ordered the beef brisket sandwich side salad and baked beans they were all wonderful it's nice little place not very big but quite comfortable ”

“ Always have the best barbecue...my favorite is mutton!... but the pork, beef and chicken, if that is your favorite. One can choose the buffet which is loaded with all your vegetables and salads. Just try and I'll guarantee you will want to return often. ”

“ Sunday afternoon November 3 at Old Hickory BBQ in Owensboro about 3:45 5 stars again because I can't do six. We both ordered the 3 meat combo meal with salads. I ordered onion rings and my wife ordered fries. Just like last time I don't know what they could have done to make it better. We both brought half our meals home. Salads were fresh and crisp. Meat was tender onion rings and fries were hot. Coors Light was ice cold. Brought home a gallon of Burgos. We sampled it when we got home. 5 stars for that also. ”

“ Try the sliced mutton but do NOT miss out on the ribs. My friend is from Owensboro and this is her fam go-to & a must stop for me too when in town. I got ribs this time and the flavor is unmatched to any I have had before. Tender with a light sauce that is extremely savory. The sliced mutton sandwich is a great bite. Their potato salad is not to my liking with it being minced up, no mustard, and a bit bland. The mac and cheese was good and go for the burgoo if they aren't sold out! ”

“ This is the place to try Owensboro style BBQ. I wouldn't necessarily say KY style, as I've yet to find another joint outside Owensboro that cooks up mutton as a staple option. Maybe it's a western KY thing, but passing though Louisville, mutton was nowhere to be found. Anyway here at Old Hickory you can find it sliced, chopped, as ribs, in a stew (burgoo) as well as the typical brisket, chicken and pork options. but owensboro style is all about the mutton, and for me, that's the chopped mutton on the white bun. Vinegary and delicious, mutton's a different bbq ball-game. the sheep oil or lanolin, adds a unique flavor that can seem strong to the uninitiated. However, I find that if you go for the experience, you will easily acclimate. The cornbread was more of a cornmeal pancake, not the typical yellow cake-looking type. The baked beans are good, but very sweet. Same with the coleslaw. The green beans are heavily cooked, so are very soft and on the darker side. I think it's a regional preparation. The catfish was nice, more crust than fish, and wasn't really served with anything like a tartar sauce or remoulade. Good for groups, friendly service and top notch bbq, make this casual eatery our regular stop every time we're in town. Come with an appetite, but I recommend fibering up before hand. I also recommend eating there (unless you're a regular). Delivered BBQ just seems different, even though it should be the same. ”

“ So rare do I give a 5-star review for a restaurant, but this one totally deserved it. First off, the girl who took care of me (Ella) is a total dream. So patient with me when I told her it was my first-time ordering. I ordered a half rack of ribs and a container of baked beans. They also let me try the potato salad which was also da' bomb but my wife got that, and I got the beans and we shared. The ribs were meaty and full of flavor. They bill the sauce as a "sweet heat", but I didn't sense any heat just a lot of really good flavor. Very happy with my purchase and will go back whenever I am in that part of the woods again. Also - they DO give military discount so thumbs up for that as well ”

“ Relatively good barbecue in a casual, country cafe type environment. The brisket was tender and flavorful. Service was great, and the cole slaw is an all-time favorite. ”

“ Came here right around opening on a Tuesday (for breakfast I guess?) and as you'd imagine there was next to no one there. I had been excited to try Kentucky style bbq since finding out about it at the museum of southern food and beverage in New Orleans, and my experience absolutely lived up to the hype! The service was fast and very friendly, giving helpful recommendations, taking me through all the different bbq sauce options, and frequently checking if I needed anything I knew the mutton was the speciality, so I had the ribs and regular mutton in a combo platter, in addition to a quarter chicken, beans, and a cup of burgoo. Mutton was absolutely the start of the show, unbelievably rich and delicious. I didn't get any gaminess or weird taste, if you've had lamb before I'd best describe it as a noticeably fattier version. The region is known for its bbq sauce using Worcestershire sauce as a base, and the almost black color of their sauce along with the flavor leads me to believe they used it, though I didn't ask. It was a really nice middle ground between steak sauce and bbq sauce that I wish was more readily available The chicken was also very tasty, but nothing you can't find in other region's bbq. The burgoo came out first and I really liked it when it was the only food I had while incredibly hungry, but after comparing it to the main course I wasn't the biggest fan. I'll caveat that this was my first burgoo experience, so possible it just isn't my jam as a dish. The beans were also nothing special, could have easily been bbq beans from a can. I think if I were a local and desensitized to the novelty of mutton in bbq, I'd probably give this spot 4 stars (especially if the mutton quality is comparable at other spots). However the great mutton experience and friendly, welcoming environment is enough to overcome the somewhat uninspiring other parts of my meal. Overall I highly recommend the trek to this region for any bbq fanatic ”

“ Come here for "Down Home Kentucky Barbecue!" A 106 year old barbecue institution and one of the few places where you can enjoy barbecue mutton. And yes, you definitely want to try it! We ordered takeout today and took it to a local park to eat. But, there is plenty of seating inside the restaurant. You order your food at a counter right next to the covered steam table holding chopped mutton, barbecue chickens, baked beans, and barbecue pork ribs. All of those looked really good. We ordered several sandwiches (all with onions and pickles) and a few sides today. My favorite sandwiches, in order, were: 1. Sliced Pork (flavorful and a large portion) 2. Chopped Mutton (good texture and flavor) 3. BBQ Bologna (flavorful and moist) 4. Sliced Mutton (tasty, but much less meat than the pork sandwich) The chopped mutton is mixed with sauce and it works well on a sandwich. I can't see it working well on a plate with 2 sides. That's a better role for the sliced mutton. I bought a jar of "John's Sweet Heat Bar-B-Q Sauce" and it was delicious! The flavors were fantastic, with just a bit of heat, and it worked well on all of the sandwiches. The Sweet Heat Sauce is a must when you are here. The Cole slaw and the potato salad were both good, but not great. Sandwich sizes and individual sides are smaller than you'd expect, but the prices are fair. Staff are friendly and very helpful. I definitely recommend Old Hickory Bar-B-Q! ”

“ Visited family in Rockport, IN and we all decided we wanted some good BBQ. They had taken us to Moonlite before so they decided they wanted to show us another favorite spot - Old Hickory Bar-B-Que. I got the brisket with mac and cheese and onion rings. The brisket was really tasty. It had a more vinegar-heavy flavor than I'm used to but the smoke ring was beautiful and it was tender. The mac and cheese was creamy and the onion rings were crispy. I really enjoyed everything, and our server was on top of things the whole time. Would definitely recommend stopping by if you're in the area. ”